We are currently developing a new site to host the Patent Manual of Practice and Procedure. The BETA version of this site is now available for you to review. The information and content displayed in the BETA site is only available for testing purposes. Do not use or reference the information in the BETA site when making any decisions or actions regarding IP rights. Tips on Claim Construction

Date Published

In some cases, it may not be readily apparent that a claim defines or includes a non-patentable collocation or kit of known integers, or whether the claim defines a patentable combination. Care should be taken to construe the claims and determine whether there is a patentable combination.

In general, the following will be considered patentable combinations, provided there is no indication in the specification that any terms are intended to be interpreted differently:

  • A composition comprising A and B.
  • A formulation comprising A and B.
  • A mixture comprising A and B.
  • A cell culture comprising cell A and cell B.
  • A cell population comprising cell A and cell B, provided the cells are derived from different sources or tissues and are unlikely to be naturally occurring in this form (see Micro-Organisms and Other Life Forms).

However, claims such as the following define non-patentable “kits” or collocations:

  • A pharmaceutical which includes combinations of known integers A and B for separate, sequential or simultaneous use. This reference may be provided as an explicit definition in the claim or as a ‘dictionary’ in the description.

    In this case, the definition of separate or sequential use clearly requires that the dosage forms are separate integers and, as a consequence, the pharmaceutical is a kit. Such kits may be referred to as a “composition”, “combination’ or ‘formulation”, however this does not change their nature and a manner of manufacture objection should be taken.

  • A pharmaceutical composition comprising a solution of component A and a solution of component B.

    In this case, the definition of a “composition” suggests a single admixture, however the definition of separate solutions is indicative of a kit or collocation of separate integers.

  • Similarly, wording such as an “article of manufacture”, a “package”, a “system”, a “kit of parts” and a “free combination”, indicates that the individual integers are merely collocated.

Back to top