4.4.1 Three Person Team (3PT) / Proportionate 3PT Consultation

Date Published

In conducting original searches of national and international applications, the primary search examiner will determine and maintain responsibility for the search strategy and search outcome. The primary search examiner may decide whether consultation is required having regard to the complexity, risk and subject matter of the case. Any consultation undertaken must support an economical search with a high probability of identifying relevant prior art, and must take into account the inventive concept and any earlier search results.


Why consultation

Consultation should be used where it will materially improve the quality, efficiency or defensibility of the search. In particular, consultation should be considered where the case spans multiple technical fields, where the primary examiners preliminary searching has not identified relevant prior art, or where the search returns a high volume of documents and input is needed to assess whether further searching is warranted. Three person team consultation may still apply for defined cohorts, including trainee examiners, examiners on performance improvement arrangements, or other examiners as directed by their manager.


Composition of consultation

Where consultation is required, the search examiner may consult one or more examiners with relevant searching experience or technical expertise. The number of secondary examiners consulted, and the timing of consultation must be determined by the needs of the case. Consultation should be targeted to the issue on which input is required. Where the technology or scope of the search extends beyond the examiner’s core expertise, the search examiner should consult an examiner with relevant experience in that field.


Role of consultation

Each secondary examiner consulted should provide independent and constructive input on the issue for which consultation is sought. This may include classification, search terms, search logic, search areas, database selection, or whether further searching is warranted. The search examiner must consider that input and determine the final search strategy.


Review of search strategy and search results

Searching is an iterative process. The search examiner can seek consultation before, during, or after the search where review of the strategy or results would assist, including where unexpected results are obtained or further guidance is needed on extending or concluding the search. Responsibility for determining whether an identified exception applies to the search strategy rests with the search examiner.

Amended Reasons

Amended Reason Date Amended

Edited to reflect new proportionate three-person team practice

Removing references to EPOQUE

Back to top

This document is controlled. Its accuracy can only be guaranteed when viewed electronically.

IP Australia | Delivering a world leading IP system