Welcome to the new version of the Patents Manual. Please note there are changes to the numbering and sequence of the chapters and pages in the manual. You are encouraged to take the time to explore and familiarise yourself with this new structure.

8.5.5 Determining the Problem

Date Published

The starting point in the "problem-solution" approach to inventive step is identifying a problem that the claimed invention solves. The problem is the focal point for the analysis and provides a context for:

  • identifying the person skilled in the art;

  • determining the relevant common general knowledge;

  • determining whether the person skilled in the art could, before the priority date of the relevant claim, be reasonably expected to have ascertained, understood, regarded as relevant and, where applicable, combined the prior art information; and

  • evaluating the relevance of the prior art information and whether there is invention in solving the problem.

Examiners should objectively determine a problem that the claimed invention solves. They should identify as narrow a problem as possible, but must avoid including any part of the solution in the phrasing of the problem, to avoid an ex post facto analysis of inventive step.

Amended Reasons

Amended Reason Date Amended
Back to top